54: The Police (B-→C)

The Police in tier list

got some classics but mostly just fine and not great 

RELISTEN1: I feel I had a pretty solid handle on this band before this relisten, on how they sound and how I feel about them. But, I was thinking about them and I realized they’d fit much better as a C, and I had to check. My impression in the relisten is that my first impression was spot on. They’ve got some classics, some pretty killer songs sprinkled in that are famous (and for good reason), but then the rest of their catalogue is filled out by weak, aimless, forgettable songs. For the most part I don’t much like ‘em, barring what is a not insignificant but still relatively small amount of notable exceptions. Which, yeah, makes more sense as a C

Leave a comment